Crime & Detective

Confessions Live: The Puppetmaster of Cold Cases

Reading Settings

16px

I taste sugar and stormwater the second I step out. The creek behind the studio has wandered down the block to meet us, turning the street into a smear of mirror where the cherubs double and sway. The Orpheum sleeps with its eyes open. The Night Choir presses at the barricades in quiet knots—pins bright as small planets, phones tipped down for once. I lift my mic and choose a voice that can carry without daring them to cheer.

“Breathe with me,” I say, and let my inhale be audible on purpose. “This is not a finale. This is safety work. If you came for a twist, go home. If you came because you’re worried for someone, thank you. Step back to the line. We’ll say more when it’s safe to say it.”

A few heads bow. A father with a stroller pivots, actually turning away; it’s a small miracle and it matters. I scan for Juniper and find the van where we parked her—behind tinted glass, flanked by two plainclothes officers. Her text bubble pops: Here. Breathing. Don’t make me content. I tap back a heart and tuck the phone away.

Jonah moves at my shoulder with the steady economy that calms me: coil, check, glance, nod. “Decoy stream is live,” he murmurs. “Room tone loop is steady. Chat’s on slow mode. We’re good on bandwidth.”

“The creek’s going to climb,” I say. “I want the cordons nudged uphill.”

“On it,” he says, jogging to Elena.

Elena’s voice darts crisp commands across the short-range: “Two steps back with the tape. Leave a channel for EMS. No sirens unless I say.” She meets my eye for only a second, then points a two-fingered question: You steady? I nod once: Steady.

I lean back into the mic. “No chants,” I tell the crowd, and let the line hang until it’s a choice they make. “Let quiet be the shape of respect.”

Hush answers me—the strange, electric hush that feels like a stage right before a curtain, all throat and promise. A pin clinks on a jacket zipper. A kid on someone’s shoulders points up, and the pointer finger belongs to twenty, then fifty people, arrowing toward the balcony where the plaster angels have lost their noses.

Lyle appears.

He doesn’t rush it. He steps out like a man who wrote the rhythm, which he did, in his head if not on paper. He wears a dark coat that drinks the lights, and his hair is cleaner than the rest of him, which tells me he staged for this. He places his palm on the rail, then taps his ring once. The metal kiss skitters down brick, a tiny metronome we all pretend not to hear.

“Stay with me,” I whisper into my sleeve mic. “Eyes on me, not on him.”

“Copy,” Elena says, low and surgical. Barricades adjust as if the street itself breathes.

Lyle surveys the people who made him possible. He doesn’t smile; he doesn’t need to. He raises his other hand like he might bless them, and the floodlights clip the edge of something black and rectangular in his palm. Not a phone. Slimmer. A thumb rests on a single button.

Jonah’s whisper warms my ear. “You see that?”

“I see it.”

“Remote,” he says. “Probably a trigger for pre-baked feeds. Could be switching encoders, could be popping a pocket projector, could be both.”

“He brought his own oxygen,” I say. “We cut the room.”

Lyle taps the rail again—ring to metal, click to spine—and begins to talk. I don’t amplify him. The crowd, trained by years of rooms where we all think we deserve the mic, leans in. He knows how to ride that lean.

“You’ve gathered for a story,” he calls, voice floating without PA, still landing where he wants. “Not mine. Yours. Your hunger is honest. Your shame is teachable. Tonight I—”

I raise my hand and press my palm toward the crowd like a traffic cop in a cathedral. “No,” I say quietly into the pirate stream, which is feeding to thousands who stayed home. “Silence is the note we hold.” I give the Night Choir on the sidewalk the same line, body only: lips closed, eyes steady, hand flat.

The hush deepens. A ripple of phones lowers an inch. The pins on jackets look like eyes that refuse to blink. Lyle looks pleased, then irritated—confusion is a mask he rarely wears, and it doesn’t fit.

He taps the remote.

To my left, a wall across the street blooms with light: his face in grainy profile, pre-recorded, speaking different words into a crowd that isn’t here. A decoy feed splashes in bad focus—one of his old monologues layered on top of the live one. A few phones pivot, confused by the kind of spectacle that’s easy to share. I feel the tide of attention tilt.

“Jonah,” I say.

“I’m on his carrier,” Jonah says, already hacking latency with the legal knobs we agreed on. “I can’t kill it, but I can delay his mirror. He’s chasing himself by three seconds. He won’t like that.”

The old trick I remember from the van—the echo war. Lyle hears his own voice trip. Irritation pricks his mouth. He taps again. The decoy feed stutters and falls half a beat behind. He taps again and looks directly at me.

I refuse to give him my eyes.

“To the ones behind the glass,” he calls, aiming upward at windows that reflect us back, “you have always been the problem and the cure. Let me show you a third act.”

“No,” I say into the stream, soft enough that only those who chose us can hear. “We don’t watch men make third acts out of other people’s lives.”

Elena’s voice threads into my ear. “He’s moving,” she says. “Balcony-to-booth catwalk. Units two and three, shift.”

Lyle bows a fraction toward the street—his version of thank you for the house, or you’re welcome. He withdraws into the dark shoulder of the balcony door and dissolves. The crowd exhales but doesn’t erupt. The creek fingers the curb with silver, licking shoe leather. I nod to the sergeant at the tape and he nods back, grateful that no one burst into claps. We’re doing it—we’re starving his oxygen.

“Juniper?” I murmur, slipping my body between two clusters to get more eyes on the barricade.

Her reply buzzes in my pocket: Still here. Breathing. The quiet feels like a blanket.

“Stay wrapped,” I text, one thumb, eyes up.

Inside, our sequence wakes: one warm bulb at the backstage wall, then the next, a breath late, then the third with the liar’s wink. Elena’s team flows like water down a trench, not sprinting, not creeping, exactly on time. Jonah ghosts behind me, his laptop screen a floating rectangle of code.

“Lag holds,” he says. “He’s going to read it like sheet music.”

“Wrong-right ready?” I ask.

He taps the labeled switch with one finger, reverent and a little feral. “Ready.”

I switch my mic to the Park-only channel. “We’re at first cue.”

“Copy,” Elena answers, voice smaller now through concrete. “Hatch unit set.”

For a beat the city pretends nothing is happening. A bus sighs two blocks over. The factory coughs its burnt sugar into the open mouth of the night. I smell caramelized fatigue. My tongue feels like I licked a spoon.

“Talk to them,” Jonah says, chin flicking toward the crowd. “Thread.”

I lift my mic again. “Thank you for the hush,” I say, no tremor. “Keep the line. If you need water, raise a hand and an officer will help you—no rushing, no pushing. If you’re recording, pan to the ground until you hear us say statement. We won’t be saying that very often.”

“I love you, Mara,” someone calls from the back, a sigh more than a shout.

“Keep that love aimed at the living,” I answer, and the crowd breathes once, in chorus. I file the sound away because it might save me later.

The balcony door cracks again. He’s quicker than I want him to be. Lyle reappears for a single beat, a stage practice so old it might be instinct: he lets the audience see his profile a second time so they clock him as myth, not man, then he vanishes for the real work. He taps the rail with his ring once more—three taps total, his sacred number—and slips backstage for good.

“He’s on the walk,” Elena says. “Eyes on elbow.”

I picture the elbow in my mind’s black box: that tight curve where we embedded the wrong-right. I grip the mic and keep my shoulders loose. Jonah spins the tiny amplitude drift that will irritate a man who lives by metronomes. The corridor bulbs run their river.

“He’ll try the remote again,” Jonah whispers. “He’ll want the street to look at a ghost so he can move in the dark.”

He’s right. The opposite wall flickers with another decoy—this one a close-up of a mask. The Night Choir murmurs, not a surge, just a ripple. I raise my hand and they settle. I want to cry, and I won’t.

“Wrong-right,” Jonah breathes.

The elbow winks. The pattern breaks where we designed it to lie. For one aching second, nothing moves.

“Commit,” I mouth into the dark, not sure whether I’m speaking to Elena, Jonah, the crowd, or the man who taught us how attention works.

The next bulb pops on along the sealed corridor.

“He bought it,” Elena says, voice so controlled she might be narrating a surgical clamp. “Hatch team: stand.”

The creek bumps my ankle with cold, a reminder that water always finds a way forward. I step a half pace back from the barricade and nod to the officers distributing water cups. The crowd stays inside the hush. The cherubs keep their gold-flaked smirks.

Inside, a dull thunk echoes—foot to deck, heavy and sure. Another. He’s not running, which would spray fear; he’s not creeping, which would admit fear. He’s doing theater walk, heel-to-toe discipline. The third footfall lands and the lights complete their sentence toward the hatch.

“Park,” I say, “status.”

“One turn left,” she says. “We’re blacked at our end. I want him in our pocket, not spooked.”

“He’s tapping,” Jonah whispers, bent over his laptop. “Not the ring. The remote. He’s trying to pop a feed inside.”

“Inside where?” I ask.

“Backstage wall, maybe a ceiling puck. He can flood an exit with his own video if it trips. He wants to drown your radio with noise.”

“He’s not the only one with switches,” I say. “Kill anything that answers him.”

Jonah rides the network map like a conductor who wants silence to land like a chord. “Nulling the pucks,” he mutters. “Dropping the rogue encoder to a sandbox. He still thinks he’s flooding; he’s peeing into a jar.”

I laugh once, the one sharp spike I can afford, then flatten to calm again. The crowd doesn’t flinch; they’re reading my shoulders more than my words now. I catch the eyes of a kid with a moon pin and give him a little nod like this: You’re doing great.

“Elbow passed,” Elena says. “Ten feet.”

“Copy.”

The next beat arrives with a sound I didn’t plan for: the balcony again—no man this time, just a phone tossed out from the shadow and shattering on stone. The crowd tenses. I raise my palm high, a stop sign stabbed into velvet.

“Do not rush the doors,” I say. “We are okay.”

“Five feet,” Elena says, and I can hear the breath control she trained into her body. “Hands ready.”

Jonah leans in, whisper-thin. “If he’s carrying a failsafe, it’s that remote.”

“I saw it,” I say. “Left hand.”

“Left hand,” he echoes, and places his finger over the WRONG-RIGHT switch like it’s a prayer he’s willing to say out loud.

The corridor lights finish their sentence at the hatch and hold steady, no flourish. Nothing happens for one, two, three heartbeats longer than my spine wants to tolerate.

“Park?” I say.

Her reply comes tinny through concrete and air and willpower. “Contact… stand by.”

The creek whispers nonsense at the curb. The factory coughs sweetness at the sky. The crowd keeps their hush like a vow I didn’t deserve and still received.

I close my eyes for half a second and see the elbow again—the wrong-right—the way one lie, timed well, can convert spectacle into a corridor. I open my eyes on purpose and make sure my voice doesn’t shake.

“Stay with me,” I tell the sidewalk, the stream, the officers, my own ribs. “No one moves.”

The radio hisses, then clears to Elena’s clean cut. “Door—”

She stops, not for drama. For something else.

I grip the mic harder. “Elena?”

Silence in my ear is a blade I can’t see. Jonah’s finger hovers over the switch that already did its job. The last cue bulb glows on metal like a halo over a lock.

“Elena,” I say, and keep my tone level, a line that can carry weight without breaking. “Do you have him, or does he have another trick?”

The only answer I get is a soft, human sound from the hatch end of the corridor, carried through concrete and an old building’s bones—a gasp that does not belong to Lyle.

I don’t say the name I think it might be. I hold the hush like a rope and brace for the pull I know is coming.